Metro Analytics
  • Home
  • Markets
  • Intelligence
  • Indicators
  • Forecast
  • Research
  • For Investors

Explore Metro

  • Home
  • Markets
  • Intelligence
  • Indicators
  • Forecast
  • Research
  • For Investors
Metro Analytics

Institutional housing market intelligence for investors, operators, lenders, and real estate teams. Scores, forecasts, demographic signals, and portfolio-ready market context in one operating layer.

Get started free
Platform
MarketsIntelligenceIndicatorsForecastMethodology
Company
ResearchInsightsFor InvestorsContact
Legal
PrivacyTerms
Score sources
Census ACS, FRED, BEA
Research also cites NAR, Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, Redfin
Coverage
Markets, indicators, forecasts
Use
Research only, not investment advice
© 2026 Metro Analytics Inc. All rights reserved.
Data connectedData transparency applies across the platform.
Metro Analytics
  • Home
  • Markets
  • Intelligence
  • Indicators
  • Forecast
  • Research
  • For Investors

Explore Metro

  • Home
  • Markets
  • Intelligence
  • Indicators
  • Forecast
  • Research
  • For Investors
HomeInsightsHousing Affordability Explained: How Home Prices, Income, and Mortgage Rates Work Together

Affordability & Income

Housing Affordability Explained: How Home Prices, Income, and Mortgage Rates Work Together

Housing affordability is the interaction of three things: home prices, income and mortgage rates. This guide explains how the NAR Housing Affordability Index measures that relationship, what its readings mean, and why other affordability measures can tell a different story.

Published November 2, 2026·16 min read·NAR, Freddie Mac, and Atlanta Fed data

NAR Housing Affordability Index · September 2026

105.4

vs. 106.7 a year earlier · an index value, not a percentage

Freddie Mac PMMS 30-year fixed

7.24%

Week of October 29, 2026

Sources: National Association of REALTORS®, October 13, 2026; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey

Article guide

In this article

13 sections
  1. 01The Three Drivers: Home Prices, Income, and Mortgage Rates
  2. 02What the NAR Housing Affordability Index Measures
  3. 03Why an HAI of 105.4 Does Not Mean "105.4% Affordable"
  4. 04How NAR Calculates the Index, Step by Step
  5. 05Why Mortgage Rates Can Change Affordability So Quickly
  6. 06Why the HAI Is Not a Personal Affordability Calculator
  7. 07Why Affordability Indexes Differ: NAR HAI vs. the Atlanta Fed HOAM
  8. 08Affordability vs. Price-to-Income vs. Rent Burden
  9. 09Why Affordability Differs Between Metros
  10. 10What Affordability Measures Can and Cannot Tell You
  11. 11How Affordability Fits With Other Housing Indicators
  12. 12Current Snapshot: What the Latest Data Show
  13. 13The Takeaway

Housing affordability describes the relationship between what it costs to own a home and the income available to pay for it. It is not the same thing as a home's price, and it is not the same thing as a mortgage rate. It is a comparison: how large is the monthly cost of owning a typical home relative to the income of a typical household or family?

That distinction matters because each input can move on its own. Prices can rise while incomes rise faster. Mortgage rates can fall while prices climb. Prices can ease while rates move up. The headline number people tend to watch — the price, the rate or the paycheck — tells only part of the story. Affordability is what you get when you put them together.

Two widely cited indicators show how this works in practice, and they are built differently:

  • The National Association of REALTORS® Housing Affordability Index (HAI) registered 105.4 for September 2026, down from 106.7 a year earlier, according to NAR's October 13, 2026 existing-home sales release.
  • The Atlanta Fed Home Ownership Affordability Monitor (HOAM) reported, for August 2026, a median household income of $86,656, a median home price of $406,000, and an estimated monthly ownership cost of $3,172, equal to 43.9% of income.

These readings are not interchangeable. They use different income measures, down-payment assumptions and definitions of monthly cost, so they should not be averaged or treated as one scale.

This article explains how the measures are built and what they can and cannot tell you. It does not forecast prices or rates, and it does not say whether now is a good time to buy or sell.

The Three Drivers: Home Prices, Income, and Mortgage Rates

Most affordability measures combine the same three ingredients.

1. Home prices

The price sets the size of the loan. For a given down-payment percentage, a higher price means a larger loan and a larger monthly payment, all else equal. Most national measures use a median price, the midpoint of homes that sold, rather than an average, so that a handful of very expensive sales does not distort the figure. A median price still reflects which homes sold in the period, so it can shift when the mix of sales changes, not only when prices change.

2. Income

Income is the other side of the ratio. It determines how large a payment a household can carry under an index's assumptions.

Indexes differ on which income they use: the NAR HAI uses median family income, while the Atlanta Fed HOAM uses median household income.

The two are defined differently: in Census terms, a household includes everyone living in a housing unit, including people who live alone, while a family is two or more people related by birth, marriage or adoption who live together.

Income data also arrive with a lag, so recent months often rely on projections or estimates.

3. Mortgage rates

The rate converts a loan balance into a monthly payment. The same loan costs more per month at a higher rate, which is why affordability can change even when prices and incomes have not.

Freddie Mac publishes its Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS) weekly, so the rate is often the fastest-moving of the three inputs.

Why lower prices do not automatically improve affordability

A falling price helps affordability only if the other two inputs do not offset it. If prices ease slightly while the mortgage rate rises, the monthly payment can still go up. If prices rise while incomes grow faster and rates hold steady, affordability can improve.

Because the three inputs move on different schedules and for different reasons, looking at any one of them alone can point in the wrong direction.

What the NAR Housing Affordability Index Measures

The NAR Housing Affordability Index asks one narrow question:

Does a typical family earn enough to qualify for a mortgage on a typical home, under a fixed set of assumptions?

NAR defines the pieces as follows:

  • The typical family is one earning the national median family income, based on U.S. Census Bureau data. For months beyond the latest Census release, NAR projects income.
  • The typical home is the national median-priced existing single-family home.
  • The loan assumes a 20% down payment and a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage.
  • The qualifying test is that the monthly principal-and-interest payment should not exceed 25% of the family's monthly income.

What a reading of 100 means

An HAI of 100 means the median family income is exactly the income needed to qualify for the median-priced existing single-family home under those assumptions.

Above 100, the median family earns more than the qualifying income.

Below 100, it earns less.

The 25% figure is an index convention, a fixed yardstick that keeps the series comparable from month to month and year to year. It is not a recommendation about how much of their income a household should spend on housing, and it is not a lending rule.

NAR Housing Affordability Index · scale

100
105.4 · September 2026
106.7 · September 2025
Below 100100 = exactly qualifiesAbove 100

These are index values, not percentages of homes that are affordable.

Why an HAI of 105.4 Does Not Mean "105.4% Affordable"

A common misreading treats the index as a percentage of affordability, as if 105.4 meant the market is 105.4% affordable, or that 5.4% of homes are within reach.

It means neither.

An HAI of 105.4 means the median family income is about 105.4% of the income needed to qualify for the median-priced existing single-family home, under NAR's assumptions.

It is a ratio of two incomes:

the income the typical family has, divided by the income the typical purchase requires.

A hypothetical to make the ratio concrete

ILLUSTRATIVE ONLY: the figures below are invented purely to show the ratio. They are not NAR's actual qualifying income.

  • Suppose the qualifying income for the median-priced home were $100,000.
  • Suppose the median family income were $105,400.
  • The index would be ($105,400 ÷ $100,000) × 100 = 105.4.

In that example, the typical family has about 5.4% more income than the qualifying threshold.

That is the full meaning of the 5.4 above 100.

It says nothing about how many individual buyers can afford a home, or how many homes are priced within reach.

What a change in the index means

The move from 106.7 to 105.4 means the cushion between median family income and qualifying income narrowed over the year.

It does not mean affordability fell by "1.3%."

The 1.3 is a difference in index points.

A percentage change in the index, the way NAR reports its regional year-over-year comparisons, is a different calculation.

How NAR Calculates the Index, Step by Step

The HAI is a short chain of arithmetic:

  1. Start with the median price of existing single-family homes sold.
  2. Subtract the down payment. NAR assumes 20%, so the loan is 80% of the price.
  3. Apply a mortgage rate. NAR uses an effective 30-year fixed rate. Its published description ties this rate to Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed-rate data, including points and fees.
  4. Compute the monthly principal-and-interest payment on that loan over 30 years.
  5. Find the qualifying income, the income at which that payment equals 25% of monthly income. Equivalently, multiply the monthly payment by 4 and then by 12.
  6. Divide the median family income by the qualifying income and multiply by 100.

HAI = (median family income ÷ qualifying income) × 100

A hypothetical walk-through

ILLUSTRATIVE ONLY: the numbers below are invented to illustrate the steps. They are not NAR's inputs for any month.

Illustrative only

A hypothetical HAI walk-through

Invented figures to show the steps — not NAR's inputs for any month

A hypothetical HAI walk-through
StepHypothetical value
Median price$400,000
Down payment (20%)$80,000
Loan amount$320,000
Mortgage rate (30-year fixed)6.50%
Monthly principal and interestabout $2,023
Qualifying incomeabout $97,100
Median family income$100,000
HAIabout 103

Swipe horizontally to view all columns →

Illustrative arithmetic only — not NAR's published inputs for any month.

In this example the median family earns about 3% more than the income needed to qualify, so the index sits slightly above 100.

Because NAR holds the down payment, loan term and 25% ratio fixed, any change in the reading comes from a change in price, rate or income.

That consistency is what makes the series comparable over time.

For how Metro Analytics documents its sources and data periods, see the Methodology.

Median price
→
20% down
→
Loan amount
→
Monthly P&I
→
Qualifying income
→
Compare with median family income
→
HAI
1
Median price
2
20% down
3
Loan amount
4
Monthly P&I
5
Qualifying income
6
Compare with median family income
7
HAI

NAR holds these assumptions constant: 20% down, a 30-year fixed rate, and a 25% principal-and-interest threshold.

Why Mortgage Rates Can Change Affordability So Quickly

Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average can move from one week to the next, while median prices and incomes are measured over longer periods and tend to shift more gradually.

For context, the PMMS reported a 30-year fixed average of 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026, compared with 7.32% the prior week and 6.17% a year earlier.

In an index like the HAI, a higher rate raises the monthly payment on the same loan, and a higher payment raises the qualifying income.

The figures below apply the HAI's own arithmetic — qualifying income = monthly payment × 4 × 12 — to a hypothetical $320,000 loan. They illustrate the mechanism only and are not a recalculation of NAR's September index.

One year before Oct. 29, 2026

6.17%

Monthly P&Iabout $1,954
Implied qualifying incomeabout $93,800

PMMS 30-year average, week of October 29, 2026

7.24%

Monthly P&Iabout $2,181
Implied qualifying incomeabout $104,700

Hypothetical $320,000 loan · difference: about $227/month

Illustrative arithmetic — not market data.

With nothing else changed, the higher rate raises the monthly payment by roughly $227 and the implied qualifying income by roughly $10,900, about 11.6% in each case.

Put another way, holding the payment at about $1,954 at 7.24% would support a loan of roughly $287,000, about $33,000 smaller.

A rate change of that size can offset a meaningful price decline or income gain.

The PMMS is an average of rates on new loan applications. It describes conditions for a new borrower, not what existing owners pay.

Keep the time periods separate

Three different time frames appear in this article, and they should not be blended:

  • September 2026: the NAR HAI reading of 105.4.
  • August 2026: the Atlanta Fed HOAM figures.
  • Week of October 29, 2026: the Freddie Mac PMMS rate of 7.24%, used here as current context only. It is not part of the September HAI.

The September HAI therefore says nothing on its own about how late-October rates will show up in a later reading; that will also depend on prices and incomes in that later period.

Why the HAI Is Not a Personal Affordability Calculator

The HAI describes a national, hypothetical median purchase.

It is not designed to tell any individual whether they can afford a home.

What the index leaves out

The HAI counts principal and interest only.

Real monthly housing costs usually include more, depending on the home and the owner:

  • Property taxes
  • Homeowners insurance
  • Private mortgage insurance, when the down payment is below 20%
  • Homeowners association dues, where they apply
  • Utilities, maintenance and repairs

It also leaves out closing costs and other cash needed up front, as well as a buyer's other debts, credit history and savings.

Assumptions that may not match your situation

  • Down payment. Many buyers put down less than 20%, and some put down more. A different down payment changes the loan size and, below 20%, may add mortgage insurance.
  • Loan type. Other loan terms and structures produce different payments than a 30-year fixed.
  • Income. A household's actual income may be well above or below the median family income.
  • The home. Homes in a given market, and the kind of home a particular buyer wants, may cost far more or less than the national median.

The HAI is best read as a trend indicator:

a consistent yardstick showing whether the combined effect of prices, rates and median income has made the typical purchase easier or harder to qualify for.

A real purchase decision would need to rest on a household's own finances and a lender's actual figures, and some buyers may want help from a qualified housing counselor or financial professional.

Why Affordability Indexes Differ: NAR HAI vs. the Atlanta Fed HOAM

A reader who sees a NAR HAI above 100 and an Atlanta Fed measure showing 43.9% of income going to housing might reasonably ask which one is right.

Neither measure is a universal definition of affordability.

They answer related but different questions using different assumptions.

Side by side

Side by side

NAR HAI vs. Atlanta Fed HOAM

Different questions, different assumptions — not directly comparable

NAR HAI vs. Atlanta Fed HOAM
FeatureNAR HAIAtlanta Fed HOAM
Question it asksCan the median family qualify for the median-priced existing single-family home?What share of income does owning a typical home cost, relative to a threshold?
Income measureMedian family incomeMedian household income
Down payment20%10%
Monthly cost includedPrincipal and interestPrincipal and interest, private mortgage insurance, property taxes and property insurance
Threshold25% of income for principal and interest30% of income for total monthly cost
Home priceMedian-priced existing single-family homeMedian home price, three-month moving average
Period used hereSeptember 2026August 2026

Swipe horizontally to view all columns →

Sources: NAR, October 13, 2026 release and Housing Affordability Index methodology; Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Home Ownership Affordability Monitor, August 2026.

What the Atlanta Fed reported for August 2026

According to the Atlanta Fed's HOAM, for August 2026:

  • Median household income: $86,656
  • Median home price: $406,000
  • Estimated total monthly ownership cost: $3,172
  • Share of income: 43.9%
  • Income needed to meet its 30% threshold: $126,849, which is about 46% above the median income

Why a 105.4 and a 43.9% can both be true

The two measures are not on the same scale and should not be compared number to number.

Several design differences explain the gap:

  • Broader cost definition. The HOAM adds mortgage insurance, taxes and insurance to principal and interest, so its monthly cost is larger relative to the same income.
  • Smaller down payment. The HOAM assumes 10% down rather than 20%, which means a larger loan.
  • Different threshold. 25% of income for principal and interest under HAI versus 30% of income for total cost under HOAM.
  • Different income measure. Family income and household income describe different groups.
  • Different months. September for the HAI and August for the HOAM, with different price and rate inputs.

Affordability vs. Price-to-Income vs. Rent Burden

Three measures often get lumped together as "affordability," but each describes something different.

Three different questions

Affordability, price-to-income, and rent burden

Affordability, price-to-income, and rent burden
MeasureWhat it comparesWhat it leaves out
Affordability index, such as HAIIncome vs. the income needed to qualify for a typical mortgageAnything not included in its assumptions
Price-to-incomeHome price ÷ incomeMortgage rate and monthly payment
Rent burdenRent ÷ income for rentersAnything about owning

Swipe horizontally to view all columns →

Each measure answers a related but distinct question about housing cost.

Price-to-income

A price-to-income ratio asks how many years of income a typical home costs.

Using the Atlanta Fed's August 2026 figures:

$406,000 ÷ $86,656 ≈ 4.7

This is a derived ratio from those published figures.

The ratio is simple and easy to compare across places, but it ignores the mortgage rate.

The same ratio produces a very different monthly payment at 6.17% than at 7.24%.

That is why a price-to-income ratio can stay flat while an affordability index moves, and the reverse.

Rent burden

Rent burden measures how much of a renter household's income goes to rent.

It is not a measure of homeownership affordability.

Renting and buying involve different costs and tradeoffs, so a rent-burden figure and a homeownership index describe different households facing different costs.

Comparing them directly can mislead, and neither says whether renting or buying is the better choice for a particular household.

When a headline calls housing "unaffordable," it is worth asking which of these it means.

A claim about price-to-income, one about a mortgage-qualifying index and one about renters' costs can each be accurate and still point in different directions.

Why Affordability Differs Between Metros

A national index blends many local markets into one number.

NAR's October 13, 2026 release shows the spread even at the regional level:

compared with a year earlier, affordability declined in:

  • Northeast: -4.5%
  • Midwest: -3.1%
  • South: -0.4%

and rose in:

  • West: +1.0%

A single national reading of 105.4 hides that variation.

At the metro level, the same drivers apply but combine differently.

Local median prices and local incomes both vary from place to place, and what matters for affordability is how they compare.

Mortgage-rate conditions often move in the same broad national direction, while local prices, incomes, taxes and insurance costs can create larger differences between metro affordability readings.

The Atlanta Fed's HOAM also reports at the metro level.

For August 2026, its summary indicated that roughly 82% of the metros it tracks were above its 30% income threshold.

That is a statement about the HOAM's threshold, not a verdict that most metros are unaffordable by every standard.

Reading local data well

  • Compare a metro with itself over time before comparing it with other metros.
  • Check which measure a local report uses — price-to-income, a qualifying index, or share of income. A metro can rank differently on each.
  • Check the income measure. Household income, family income and individual wages are not interchangeable.
  • Remember that a metro-level median is still a summary, and neighborhoods within a metro can differ widely.

See metro housing market data for individual market context.

Year-over-year change in HAI · by region

Northeast
-4.5%
Midwest
-3.1%
South
-0.4%
West
+1%

Percentage change in each region's HAI versus a year earlier, not a home-price or dollar comparison.

What Affordability Measures Can and Cannot Tell You

What they can tell you

  • Direction over time. Because the assumptions stay fixed, an index like the HAI shows whether a typical purchase has become easier or harder to qualify for than in an earlier period. The move from 106.7 to 105.4 over a year is an example.
  • Which driver is doing the work. Looking at price, income and rate alongside the index helps show why a reading changed.
  • How definitions change the picture. Comparing two indexes, as with the HAI and the HOAM, shows how much the answer depends on what is counted.

What they cannot tell you

  • Whether a specific household can buy a specific home. That depends on its own income, debts, savings, credit and loan terms.
  • Whether homes are available. An index describes the cost of a typical purchase, not how many homes are for sale.
  • Whether it is a good time to buy or sell, or where prices and rates go next. These indexes describe measured past and present conditions. They are not forecasts and do not recommend any action.
  • How different groups are affected. A median describes the middle. First-time buyers, higher-income buyers and renters may each face a different picture.

No single threshold defines when housing becomes "unaffordable."

The HAI's 25% and the HOAM's 30% are conventions chosen for measurement.

Reading an index as a verdict rather than a yardstick tends to overstate what it can show.

How Affordability Fits With Other Housing Indicators

Affordability is one lens on the housing market.

It works best alongside indicators that measure different things.

Prices

Home price indexes such as the FHFA House Price Index track how prices change over time, but say nothing on their own about rates or income.

Sales activity

Existing-home sales and pending home sales show how many transactions are closing or going under contract.

They describe activity, not cost.

Supply

Housing inventory measures how many homes are for sale, which an affordability reading cannot show.

Builder sentiment

The NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index measures builders' views of market conditions, a different question from household affordability.

If the HAI declines, the next question is which input drove it.

Putting a price index, a rate series and an income series next to the reading helps separate those effects, and sales and inventory data show whether the same conditions are appearing in activity and supply.

Because these indicators are published on different schedules and cover different periods, lining them up means checking each one's reference month rather than assuming they describe the same moment.

Housing Affordability
Prices
Income
Mortgage rates
Sales activity
Supply
Builder sentiment

Related indicators, each measuring a different part of the housing market.

Current Snapshot: What the Latest Data Show

The table collects the latest figures cited in this article.

The periods differ, so the rows should be read separately rather than combined.

Current snapshot

What the latest data show

What the latest data show
IndicatorPeriodReadingSource
NAR Housing Affordability IndexSeptember 2026105.4, versus 106.7 a year earlierNAR, October 13, 2026
Freddie Mac 30-year fixed-rate averageWeek of October 29, 20267.24%; 7.32% prior week; 6.17% a year earlierFreddie Mac PMMS
Atlanta Fed HOAM: median household incomeAugust 2026$86,656Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Atlanta Fed HOAM: median home priceAugust 2026$406,000Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Atlanta Fed HOAM: estimated monthly costAugust 2026$3,172, 43.9% of incomeFederal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Atlanta Fed HOAM: income needed at 30% thresholdAugust 2026$126,849Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta

Swipe horizontally to view all columns →

Periods differ — do not combine.

  • The NAR HAI stayed above 100 in September 2026 but was lower than a year earlier: the median family income still exceeded the qualifying income under NAR's assumptions, by a smaller margin.
  • Under the Atlanta Fed's assumptions, the August 2026 monthly ownership cost equaled 43.9% of median household income, above its 30% threshold.
  • The 7.24% PMMS rate is context for current borrowing conditions. It is not an input to the September HAI, and this article does not recalculate the HAI with it.

NAR's next Existing-Home Sales report is scheduled for November 12, 2026 at 10 a.m. ET. Recheck the latest HAI before publishing after that date.

The Takeaway

Housing affordability is a relationship between three things:

what homes cost, what the loan costs to carry, and what households earn.

No single one of them tells you whether homes are affordable, and a change in one can be offset by a change in another.

  • Know what the number is. An HAI of 105.4 means the median family income is about 105.4% of the income needed to qualify for the median-priced existing single-family home under NAR's assumptions, not that housing is "105.4% affordable."
  • Know what is assumed. 20% down, a 30-year fixed rate, principal and interest only and a 25% yardstick are measurement conventions, not advice.
  • Know why measures differ. The Atlanta Fed's HOAM counts more costs, assumes 10% down and uses household income and a 30% threshold, so its numbers will not match the HAI's.
  • Keep the periods straight. The September HAI, August HOAM and late-October mortgage rates describe different times.
  • Use indexes for direction, not personal decisions. They show how conditions have changed. They do not say whether a particular household can afford a particular home, and they do not forecast what comes next.

When the next HAI reading arrives, the most useful question is which of the three drivers moved.

Sources

  • NAR — Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report
  • NAR — Housing Affordability Index
  • Freddie Mac — Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS)
  • Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta — Home Ownership Affordability Monitor
  • Metro Analytics — Methodology

Editorial analysis for informational purposes only. Not investment, legal, or financial advice.

Continue exploring Metro Analytics

  • Explore Markets
  • View Methodology